Dark Messiah of Might and Magic Review @ GameSpot

It's basically an Action/FPS/Adventure. The gamespot review is asinine but it did what they wanted and that's increase traffic to that piss poor excuse of a site.

 

Because it is probably the same reviewers that called Diablo an RPG, or RTS games as wargames and perhaps even AFterburner as a flight simulator.
They can call an orange apple all they want, it is still an orange.